Broadband News

Tweaks for ECI VDSL2 cabinets may boost speeds for some

The manufacturer of the DSLAM within the VDSL2 cabinet is not something any of us get to choose and our forums have had people reporting the success of various initiatives on Huawei cabinets such as G.INP and the xdB roll-out that have boosted their speeds particularly the download speed.

The last few days has seen Openreach announce that xdB noise margins are to be run through a proof of concept trial on ECI cabinets (oddly one or two claim to have already seen this in their modem stats, but the wider data set suggests that nothing major has taken place yet). xdB for those not aware means that rather than the VDSL2 modem syncing at a 6dB noise margin, if the Dynamic Line Management system believes the line is stable at a 6dB target noise margin a setting of 5dB will be applied giving you a little more speed, and then after a while if that is stable a target of 4dB is tested and then 3dB. This can give people a few more Meg of speed, but for those at the maximum sync speed e.g. 39999Kbps for 40/2 and 40/10 products, and 79999 Kbps for 80/20 nothing will change. The reduction in target noise margin is not permanent and if the DLM sees enough errrors it will return you to a higher target noise margin.

Observed speed difference between ECI and Huawei VDSL2 cabinets
Click image for larger version

Median download speeds for Huawei and ECI cabinets plotted over time. Based on analysis of the users speed tests via thinkbroadband.com/speedtest and other sites that use our testing technology.

The result of the xDB and G.INP improvements (note ECI is not getting G.INP yet - this impulse noise protection algorithm can boost speeds too) is pretty obvious when you look at how the speeds of FTTC users on ECI and Huawei cabinets has changed since 2015. While a gap of 3 Mbps may not sound much, for users in the 20 to 25 Mbps region it can be the difference between ultra HD video streaming smoothly or seeing the buffer symbol of doom every few minutes. For users with sub superfast speeds in the 5 to 8 Mbps, even an extra 1 Mbps might be enough to make HD video streaming smooth and while the obsessive may not the change in large file download times the quality and speed of broadband is very often judged by the majority based on how well video streaming performs. The chart plots the median speed, but the mean average shows a similar pattern and has a 2.1 Mbps difference in Q2 2017.

ECI cabinets represent around 30% of the 82,000 VDSL2 cabinets (this figure does not include additional second cabinets added to increase capacity) and were largely rolled due the earlier commercial phases, almost all the BDUK project cabinets are Huawei based and with the longer line lengths you would expect as your edge into the peri-urban and rural areas the difference between the two sets of median speeds is even more suprising.

Download speed profile for Huawei cabinet users in Q2/2017
Click image for larger version

Download speeds plotted for Huawei cabinet based speed tests in Q2 2017

Download speed profile for Huawei cabinet users in Q2/2017
Click image for larger version

Download speeds plotted for ECI cabinet based speed tests in Q2 2017

Comments

So if you're on a Huawei cabinet the lowest is 3dB? I am stuck at 6dB at the moment which causes me to loose a few Mbps, no line errors or disconnections either.

  • DrMikeHuntHurtz
  • 2 months ago

Hi Broadband Watchers.
At last with the reduction from 6 DBS maybe to 3Db and with the off load of ADSl lines the Dorking Mamba Project is starting to look viable with all the claw back money spent plus with the private investment the results should hit the 99.7% at 15 Meg let's say + or - .2% with all customers above 10 Meg at a manageable price.

  • Blackmamba
  • 2 months ago

^^^ what is the "Dorking Mamba Project"?

  • baby_frogmella
  • 2 months ago

Old news. This ability to tweak Huawei kit has been known about for 12 months. It's a disgrace for marginal long cable run bbc customers with .5 to 1.5 meg sync. Not to have this change asap. JFD it you network reprobates!!

  • Webbas
  • 2 months ago

only this is about ECI kit - which is not.

  • ZenUser27
  • about 1 month ago

Post a comment

Login Register