Skip Navigation

BT opt-out of Phorm
Monday 06 July 2009 11:44:35 by John Hunt

BT has decided not to proceed with the roll-out of the advertising system Phorm which monitors user activity online to generate behavioural based advertising which is then displayed via participating websites. The controversial system has been slated in the press for both secret trials back in 2007 and a general belief from privacy campaigners that the system could be illegal due to the way it intercepts users traffic, and how users can opt-out of the system.

"We continue to believe the interest based advertising category offers major benefits for consumers and publishers alike. However, given our public commitment to developing next generation broadband and television services in the UK we have decided to weigh up the balance of resources devoted to other opportunities.

"Given these resource commitments, we don't have immediate plans to deploy Webwise today. However the interest based advertising market is extremely dynamic and we intend to monitor Phorm's progress with other ISPs and with Webwise Discover before finalising our plans."

BT Statement on Phorm

The secret trials conducted by BT and Phorm in 2007 which directed information on users browsing habits to Phorm sparked off a wider interest in the system that has been plagued by moral and legal concerns. The City of London Police ran an investigation into the legalities of its covert test of Phorm but dropped the investigation citing implied consent. Later trials of BT, which termed the system Webwise were conducted more openly, but concerns continued to exist on how individual users could opt out, particularly on shared computers.

The UK government were asked to step in to detail whether the system and implementation would satisfy their privacy laws, and the outcome that it would have to be an opt-in system was determined. The European Commission wasn't so happy though and opened a case on the 14th of April against the UK over its handling of Phorm and how it has implemented EU privacy laws. Many large websites including Amazon and Wikipedia then announced that they had requested to be excluded from any scanning by BT's Phorm system.

BT was the test case that other ISPs such as Virgin Media and TalkTalk were watching with bated breath to see how the legal and moral concerns played out. TalkTalk held fast stating from the start that any implementation they perform would be opt-in, and not an automatic inclusion as BT originally planned for their system.

Phorm remain positive about their position, and have expanded further afield with talks to potential partners in 15 other countries, including South Korea's largest ISP KT.


Posted by c_j_ over 7 years ago

Dear old Stratis Scleparis, Chief Technology Officer at BT Retail during the denied Phorm trials, and coincidentally now CTO at Phorm, might be lucky enough to spend more time with his family soon!
Posted by pcoventry76 over 7 years ago
Right so now looks like it's not going to happen on BT VM or TT so can you all stop bitching about something that was never going to happen anyway?

Posted by Drefsab over 7 years ago
I for one am very glad to read this result, people may think there was to much fuss made over it but it was exactly that level of fuss needed to make sure phorm did not get put in place in a larger wider scale.
Posted by Dawn_Falcon over 7 years ago
Posted by whatever2 over 7 years ago
Posted by kamelion over 7 years ago
Ironic because people were complaining that surfing habits would be watched and were shocked that the police did nothing about it when the government monitors all your internet traffic as a matter of course in the interests of "national security"
Posted by brucestid over 7 years ago
Kamelion, nobody likes being monitored, but Phorm's past and present dubious practices make it a bit like having the Mafia open all your mail first.
Posted by chrysalis over 7 years ago
in short the EU have caught the UK breaking privacy laws, the uk government has failed to persuade the EU to drop it and as such has told BT they best to pull out (for now), probably until some law changes legalise it.
Posted by Kaufhof over 7 years ago
I have always felt it obvious that this would not happen.
Posted by MajorBugout over 7 years ago
This is definitely one that will sit on the shelf for later. There's also the use of cookies that is being targeted for opt-in restriction
Is everybody going mad? If it ain't broke don't fix it!!
Posted by DavidTipping over 7 years ago
Just who, in the BT Kremlin, ever thought something like Phorm would EVER be acceptable to the public?
Just MORE money wasted, but do keep your eyes open; there may be an attempt to introduce something similar by stealth.
You must be logged in to post comments. Click here to login.